| Date | Name | Age | Region | Rating | Individual Ratings | Book |
| February 25, 2011 | NO SCOTCH | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | The Tender Bar by J.R. Moehringer |
| October 15, 1999 | Glenmorangie 25 year | 25 | Highland | 4.40 | When Nietzsche Wept by Irvin Yalom | |
| January 20, 2000 | Glenmorangie 18 year | 18 | Highland | 4.20 | Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austin | |
| May 21, 1999 | Cooper's Choice Glendullan | Speyside | 4.13 | The Crying of Lot 49 by Thomas Pynchon | ||
| October 10, 1997 | Glenmorangie 18 year | 18 | Highland | 4.10 | Islands in the Stream by Earnest Hemingway | |
| November 2, 2007 | The Glenlivet Nadurra | 16 | Speyside | 4.00 | Wellington, Winters, Sheridan; 4.5 Smedema, Regester; 4.0 Hoover; 3.5 Giralte; 3.0 | Intellectual Morons by Daniel Flynn |
| September 18, 2009 | Laphroig Cask Strength | 10 | Islay | 4.00 | U N A N I M O U S | Out Stealing Horses by Per Petterson |
| September 24, 2010 | Glenmorangie Astar | no age | Highland | 3.92 | Smedema, Sheridan; 4.5 Winters, Hoover, Regester; 4.0 Giralte; 2.5 | One Second After by William Forstchen |
| August 16, 2008 | Ardmore | no age | Speyside | 3.83 | Sheridan, Winters; 4.5 Smedema; 4.0 Hoover, Giralte; 3.5 Regester; 3.0 | Language Instinct by Steven Pinker |
| January 9, 2004 | Dalwhinnie | 15 | Highland | 3.80 | Hoover, Giralte; 3.5 Smedema, Sheridan, Regester; 4.0 | Tishomingo Blues by Elmore Leonard |
| September 8, 2007 | Bruichladdich | 10 | Islay | 3.80 | Winters, Smedema, Sheridan; 4.0 Hoover, Giralte; 3.5 | Atonement by Ian McEwen |
| August 28, 1998 | Bunnahabhain | Islay | 3.75 | Bonfire of the Vanities by Tom Wolfe | ||
| March 21, 2008 | Springbank | 10 | Campbeltown | 3.75 | Hoover, Sheridan, Smedema, Winters; 4.0 Regester; 3.5 Giralte; 3.0 | The Last Temptation of Christ by Nikos Kazantakis |
| March 6, 2009 | Tullibardine | 14 | Highland | 3.75 | Hoover, Winters, Sheridan; 4.0 Giralte, Regester, Smedema; 3.75 | Soldier's Heart by Elizabeth Samet |
| Jul 22, 2011 | Laphroig Cask Strength | 10 | Islay | 3.75 | Giralte; 4.5 Sheridan, Winters; 4.0 Smedema, Regester; 3.5 Hoover; 3.0 | The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo by Stieg Larsson |
| November 21, 1997 | Isle of Jura | Highland | 3.70 | Babbitt by Sinclair Lewis | ||
| March 6, 1998 | Glenlivet 18 Year | 18 | Highland | 3.70 | A Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood | |
| November 20, 1998 | Cragganmore | Speyside | 3.70 | The Tortilla Curtain by Thomas Boyle | ||
| September 8, 2000 | Glendronach 15 year | 15 | Highland | 3.70 | Giralte, Regester; 3.5 Smedema, Hoover, Sheridan; 4.0 | Special Prisoner by Jim Lehrer |
| January 7, 2005 | Clynelish 14 year | 14 | Highland | 3.70 | Giralte; 3.0 Smedema; 3.5 Hoover, Sheridan, Regester; 4.0 | Corrections by Jonathan Frantzen |
| May 9, 2008 | Ledaig | 15 | Isle of Mull | 3.67 | Regester, Sheridan; 4.0 Giralte, Winters, Hoover, Smedema; 3.5 | Childhood's End by Arthur C. Clarke |
| March 9, 2012 | Bowmore | 12 | Islay | 3.67 | Regester, Winters; 4.0 Giralte, Sheridan, Stauffer, Smedema; 3.5 | Peat, Smoke and Spirit by Andrew Jefford |
| August 3, 2007 | Glen Garioch | 21 | Highland | 3.66 | Regester, Winters; 4.0 Hoover, Sheridan, Smedema, Giralte ; 3.5 | Hegemony or Survival by Noam Chomsky |
| December 2, 2011 | Old Pulteney | 21 | Highland | 3.66 | Giralte, Smedema, Regester; 4.0 Sheridan, Winters; 3.5 Stauffer; 3.0 | Master of the Senate by Robert A. Caro |
| Apr 27, 2012 | Kilchoman | no age | Islay | 3.64 | Winters, Sheridan; 4.0 Stauffer, Giralte, Regester, Smedema, Hoover; 3.5 | Water For Elephants by Sara Gruen |
| November 22, 1996 | Glenkinchie | 10 | Lowland | 3.60 | Elmer Gantry by Sinclair Lewis | |
| April 10, 1998 | Glen Ord | Highland | 3.60 | A Year in Provence by Peter Mayle | ||
| October 2, 1998 | Longmorn | 15 | Highland | 3.60 | Paradise by Toni Morrison | |
| August 20, 1999 | Lagavulin | 16 | Islay | 3.60 | The Mole People by Jennifer Toth | |
| May 13, 2005 | Abelour / Abunadh | no age | Speyside | 3.60 | Hoover, Smedema, Giralte; 3.5 Sheridan; 4.0 | Peace Is the Way by Deepak Chopra |
| November 18, 2005 | Macallan Fine Oak 10 Year | 10 | Highland | 3.60 | Hoover, Sheridan; 4.0 Giralte; 3.5 Smedema; 3 | Three Weeks With My Brother by Nicholas Sparks |
| Jan 4, 2013 | Glenmorangie Astar | no age | Highland | 3.57 | Winters, Sheridan; 4.0 Stauffer, Giralte, Regester, Hoover; 3.5 Smedema; 3.0 | They Marched Into Sunlight by David Maraniss |
| February 7, 1997 | The Singleton | 12 | Speyside | 3.50 | Johnny Got His Gun by Dalton Trumbo | |
| March 21, 1997 | Macallan | Highland | 3.50 | Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury | ||
| May 2, 1997 | Glenmorangie PWF | 12 | Highland | 3.50 | Guerilla Prince by Georgie Ann Geyer | |
| January 15, 1999 | Oban | 14 | Highland | 3.50 | In Cold Blood by Truman Capote | |
| March 10, 2000 | The Talisker 10 year | 10 | Isle of Skye | 3.50 | Sheridan, Giralte; 3.0 Smedema, Regester; 4.0 | The Book of Job by Job |
| April 28, 2000 | Glenhaven*** | Highland | 3.50 | Hoover, Regester; 3.0 Sheridan; 3.5 Giralte, Smedema; 4.0 | Catch 22 by Joseph Heller | |
| July 8, 2000 | Dalwhinnie 15 year | 15 | Highland | 3.50 | Giralte; 3.0 Regester, Hoover; 3.5 Smedema; 4.0 | Men From Mars; Women From Venus by John Gray |
| September 21, 2001 | Lagavulin | 16 | Islay | 3.50 | Sheridan; 3.0 Smedema, Giralte; 3.5 Regester; 4.0 | The Telling by Ursula LeGuin |
| December 1, 2001 | Abelour 15 year SWF | 15 | Speyside | 3.50 | Unanimous | Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance by Robert Persig |
| May 31, 2002 | Royal Lochnager 12 year | 12 | Highland | 3.50 | Unanimous | Demon Haunted World by Carl Sagan |
| December 12, 2002 | Edradour 10 year | 10 | Highland | 3.50 | Unanimous | A Confederacy of Dunces by J. K. Toole |
| June 4, 2004 | Glenkeith 10 year | 10 | Highland | 3.50 | Giralte; 3.0 Smedema,Regester, Sheridan; 3.5 Hoover; 4.0 | Lolita by Vladimer Nabakov |
| February 16, 2007 | Caol Ila | 12 | Islay | 3.50 | Hoover; 2.5 Sheridan, Giralte, Smedema, 3.5 Winters, Regester; 4.0 | God Bless You Mr. Rosewater by Kurt Vonnegut |
| December 4, 2009 | Glenmorangie Nectar D’or | 12 | Highland | 3.50 | U N A N I M O U S | The Color Of Lightning by Paulette Jiles |
| Nov 2, 2012 | Bruichladdich Octomore | 5 | Islay | 3.50 | Stauffer, Giralte; 4.0 Sheridan; 3.5 Regester, Smedema; 3.0 | |
| April 13, 2007 | Macallan Fine Oak 15 year | 15 | Highland | 3.42 | Smedema, Regester; 3.0 Hoover, Winters, Giralte; 3.5 Sheridan; 4.0 | King's Row by Henry Bellamann |
| Sep 7, 2012 | Auchentoshan Heartwood | no age | Lowland | 3.42 | Smedema, Winters, Regester, Sheridan, Giralte; 3.5 Stauffer; 3.0 | They Eat Puppies, Don’t They? by Christopher Buckley |
| June 2, 2000 | Abelour 15 year | 15 | Speyside | 3.40 | Giralte, Regester; 3.0 Smedema; 3.5 Sheridan; 4.0 | Diamond Age by Neil Stephenson |
| March 9, 2001 | Knochado 12 year | 12 | Speyside | 3.40 | Giralte; 3.0 Smedema,Regester,Hoover; 3.5 | Hyperion by Dan Simmons |
| August 15, 2003 | Old Pulteney | Highland | 3.40 | Giralte;3.0 Smedema, Regester, Hoover; 3.5 | Stranger in a Strange Land by Robert Heinlein | |
| October 12, 2006 | Eleuthera | no age | Vatted | 3.40 | Sheridan, Hoover; 3.0 Smedema, Giralte; 3.5 Regester; 4.0 | Everyman by Phillip Roth |
| January 8, 2011 | Benriach | 10 | Speyside | 3.33 | Winters, Regester; 4.0 Sheridan, Hoover, Smedema, Giralte; 3.0 | The Rational Optimist by Matt Ridley |
| October 4, 1996 | Abelour | 10 | Speyside | 3.30 | Cycle of Violence by Colin Bateman | |
| December 1, 2000 | Royal Lochnagar 12 year | 12 | Highland | 3.30 | Giralte, Regester; 3.0 Smedema, Hoover, Sheridan; 3.5 | Last Days of Disco by Walt Stilman |
| October 24, 2002 | The Balvenie Doublewood | 12 | Highland | 3.30 | Giralte, Hoover; 3.0 Smedema; 4 | From Here to Eternity by James Jones |
| April 25, 2003 | Bunnahabhain | 12 | Islay | 3.30 | Hoover;2.5 Sheridan; 3.0 Regester, Belke; 3.5 Smedema; 4.0 | The Sparrow by Mary Doria Russell |
| March 5, 2004 | Ledaig | Isle of Mull | 3.30 | Giralte, Smedema; 3.0 Regester, Sheridan, Hoover; 3.5 | The Boys in the Band by Matthew Crowley | |
| February 11, 2005 | Macallan Sherry Cask | Highland | 3.30 | Smedema; 3.0 Sheridan, Giralte; 3.5 Regester; 4.0 | Lucky You by Carl Haiasson | |
| June 6, 2006 | The Glenlivet | 12 | Speyside | 3.30 | Regester, Sheridan; 3.0 Giralte, Smedema, Hoover; 3.5 | The Plot Against America by Phillip Roth |
| September 30, 2011 | Glenmorangie Lasanta | 12 | Highland | 3.30 | Sheridan, Smedema, Stauffer; 3.5 Giralte, Regester; 3.0 | The Taking by Dean Koontz |
| Jul 20, 2012 | Braeval Cask Strength | 12 | Speyside | 3.28 | Giralte; 4.0 Winters, Smedema, Regester; 3.5 Stauffer, Sheridan; 3.0 Hoover; 2.5 | It’s Even Worse Than It Looks by Thomas E. Mann & Norman J. Ornstein |
| October 13, 2000 | Longmorn 15 year | 15 | Highland | 3.25 | Sheridan, Giralte;3.0 Regester, Smedema; 3.5 | The Book of Revelation by The Holy Bible |
| January 5, 2001 | Tomintoul 14 year | 14 | Speyside | 3.25 | Sheridan, Regester; 3.0 Giralte, Smedema; 3.5 | As I Lay Dying by William Faulkner |
| July 21, 2001 | Dimple 15 year | 15 | Blended | 3.25 | Giralte, Sheridan; 3.0 Smedema, Hoover; 3.5 | Bobos in Paradise by David Brooks |
| January 19, 2002 | Glenkeith 10 year | 10 | Highland | 3.25 | Giralte, Regester; 3.0 Hoover, Smedema; 3.5 | The Crossing by Cormac McCarthy |
| January 23, 2003 | Glenrothes 11 year | 11 | Speyside | 3.25 | Giralte, Hoover; 3.0 Sheridan, Keith; 3.5 | The Friendly Persuasion by Jessamyn West |
| June 12, 2003 | Scapa | 12 | Orkney Isle | 3.25 | Hoover, Giralte; 3.0 Smedema, Regester; 3.5 | A Walk in the Woods by Bill Bryson |
| April 9, 2004 | Tomintoul 14 year | 14 | Speyside | 3.25 | Sheridan, Hoover; 3.0 Smedema, Giralte; 3.5 | Lamb by Christopher Moore |
| June 2, 2007 | Tamdhu | no age | Speyside | 3.25 | Giralte, Hoover, Regester; 3.5 Smedema, Winters, Sheridan; 3.0 | Wicked by Gregory Maguire |
| July 24, 2009 | Ardbeg Uigeadail | no age | Islay | 3.25 | Giralte, Winters; 4.0 Sheridan; 3.5 Smedema; 3.0 Regester, Anderson; 2.5 | Andy Kaufman Revealed by Bob Zmuda |
| July 23, 2010 | The Balvenie | 15 | Speyside | 3.25 | Smedema;3.5 Winters, Giralte; 3.25 Regester; 3.0 | History of The World in 6 Glasses by Tom Standage |
| Feb 15, 2013 | Balvenie Caribbean Cask | 14 | Speyside | 3.25 | Giralte, Smedema, Winters, Regester; 3.5 Hoover; 3.0 Stauffer; 2.5 | Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad |
| January 10, 1997 | Royal Lochnagar | 12 | Highland | 3.20 | Kurt Vonnegut Stephen Crane | Slaughterhouse Five and The Red Badge of Courage |
| April 7, 2006 | Speyburn 10 year | 10 | Highland | 3.20 | Sheridan, Hoover; 3.5 Giralte, Smedema, Regester; 3.0 | Inside the Kingdom by Carmen Bin Laden |
| December 14, 2007 | Glenfiddich Ancient Reserve | 18 | Speyside | 3.20 | Giralte, Smedema; 3.5 Sheridan, Winters, Hoover, Regester; 3.0 | Mountains Beyond Mountains by Tracy Kidder |
| April 10, 2009 | Glenfiddich Ancient Reserve | 18 | Speyside | 3.20 | Smedema, Regester; 3.5 Hoover, Giralte, Sheridan; 3.0 | The Fixer by Bernard Malamud |
| March 5, 2010 | Tomatin | 18 | Highland | 3.20 | Giralte, Smedema; 3.5 Sheridan, Winters, Hoover; 3.0 | Zeitoun by Dave Eggers |
| January 8, 2010 | Macallan Cask Strength | no age | Highland | 3.17 | Hoover, Sheridan, Giralte Winters; 3.5 Regester; 3.0 Smedema; 2.0 | Dogs Of God by James Reston, Jr. |
| May 21, 2010 | Mortlach | 13 | Speyside | 3.17 | Winters;3.75 Regester; 3.5 Giralte; 3.25 Hoover, Sheridan; 3.0 Smedema; 2.5 | The Bachmann Books by Stephen King |
| March 29, 2002 | Deanston | Highland | 3.13 | Sheridan; 3.0 Hoover, Smedema, Giralte; 3.5 | Watership Down by Richard Adams | |
| August 23, 2002 | Glendronach 15 year | 15 | Highland | 3.13 | Giralte; 3.0 Smedema, Sheridan, Regester; 3.5 | The Voyage by Phillip Caputo |
| December 7, 2006 | Auchentoshan | 12 | Lowland | 3.125 | Regester; 2.5 Sheridan; 3.0 Smedema, Hoover 3.5 | To Say Nothing of the Dog by Connie Willis |
| June 1, 2001 | McClelland | Islay | 3.10 | Regester; 2.5 Smedema, Sheridan; 3.0 Giralte, Hoover 3.5 | A Virtuous Woman by Kaye Gibbons | |
| February 27, 2003 | Glenfarclas 12 year | 12 | Highland | 3.10 | Hoover; 2.5 Regester, Giralte; 3.0 Smedema, Sheridan; 3.5 | The Power and the Glory by Graham Greene |
| August 13, 2004 | Highland Park 18 year | 18 | Orkney Isle | 3.10 | Hoover; 2.5 Smedema, Sheridan; 3.0 Regester, Giralte; 3.5 | A Short History of the World by Bill Bryson |
| March 3, 2006 | Glengoyne | 17 | Highland | 3.10 | Giralte;3.5 Smedema, Regester, Hoover, Sheridan 3.0 | Chronicles by Bob Dylan |
| July 22, 2006 | Glenfiddich Solera Reserve | 15 | Speyside/Pure | 3.10 | Regester, Sheridan, Smedema, Giralte; 3.0 Hoover; 3.5 | False Memory by Dean Koontz |
| August 31, 2006 | Bunnahabhain | 12 | Islay | 3.10 | Hoover; 2.5 Giralte, Sheridan; 3.0 Regester, Smedema; 3.5 | Playing God in Yellowstone by Alston Chase |
| January 25, 2008 | Aberfeldy | 12 | Highland | 3.10 | Giralte, Winters; 3.5 Smedema, Regester, Hoover; 3.0 Sheridan; 2.5 | Ivanhoe by Sir Walter Scott |
| July 26, 1996 | The Balvenie | 12 | Speyside | 3.00 | Cancer Ward by Alexander Solzhenitsyn | |
| January 24, 1998 | Cardhu | Highland | 3.00 | A Prayer For Owen Meany by John Irving | ||
| July 10, 1998 | Highland Park | 12 | Orkney Isle | 3.00 | A Canticle for Liebowitz by Walter Miller | |
| November 7, 2003 | Scapa | 12 | Orkney Isle | 3.00 | Unanimous | Abandon Ship: USS Indianapolis by Richard Newcomb |
| November 19, 2010 | Glen Garioch | no age | Highland | 3.00 | Winters; 3.5 Regester, Sheridan, Hoover, Smedema; 3.0 Giralte; 2.5 | Charlie Wilson’s War by George Crile |
| April 22, 2011 | The Arran | 10 | Isle of Arran | 3.00 | Smedema, Giralte, Winters; 3.5 Sheridan, Regester, Hoover; 2.5 | Lady Chatterley’s Lover by D. H. Lawrence |
| Nov 2, 2012 | Benriach | 21 | Speyside | 3.00 | Stauffer, Smedema; 3.5 Sheridan, Giralte; 3.0 Regester; 2.0 | The Satanic Verses by Salmon Rushdie |
| June 19, 2009 | Glenfiddich | 18 | Speyside | 2.93 | Giralte; 3.0 Sheridan, Smedema, Regester, Winters, Hoover; 2.5 Evans; 2.0 | |
| June 13, 1997 | Glen Deveron | Highland | 2.90 | Selected Works of Allen Ginsberg by Allen Ginsberg | ||
| May 29, 1998 | Dalmore 12 Year | 12 | Highland | 2.90 | Angela's Ashes by Frank McCourt | |
| October 14, 2004 | Little Mill 8 year | 8 | Lowland | 2.90 | Giralte; 2.5 Regester, Hoover, Smedema; 3.0 | A Spoon River Anthology by Edgar Lee Masters |
| December 3, 2004 | Auchentoshan | 10 | Lowland | 2.90 | Hoover, Garing; 2.5 Regester, Giralte; 3.0 Smedema; 3.5 | Deliverance by James Dickey |
| June 17, 2005 | McClelland | Islay | 2.90 | Hoover, Hoover; 2.5 Smedema, Giralte, Sheridan; 3.0 Regester; 3.5 | Gods, Guns and Rock'n Roll by Ted Nugent | |
| January 6, 2006 | Ardbeg | 10 | Islay | 2.90 | Regester;3.5 Smedema, Giralte; 3.0 Sheridan, Hoover; 2.5 | The House of the Scorpion by Nancy Farmer |
| January 20, 2012 | Maclinlay’s (Shackleton’s) | no age | Highland | 2.90 | Smedema, Giralte; 3.5 Sheridan; 3.0 Winters ; 2.5 Regester ; 2.0 | Moby Dick by Herman Melville |
| November 14, 2008 | Isle of Jura | 16 | Highland | 2.83 | Hoover, Sheridan; 2.5, Wellington, Regester, Winters, Smedema; 3.0 | Straight Man by Richard Russo |
| August 22, 1997 | Sheep Dip | 8 | Highland | 2.80 | Lord of the Flies by William Goldberg | |
| April 27, 2001 | Laphroig 10 year | 10 | Islay | 2.80 | Hoover, 1.0 Regester, Smedema, Belke; 3.0 Giralte;4.0 | Silence of the Lambs by Thomas Harris |
| August 12, 2005 | Tobermory 10 year | 10 | Isle of Mull | 2.80 | Regester; 2.0 Hoover; 2.5 Smedema, Giralte; 3.0 Sheridan; 3.5 | Facts Behind the Helsinki Roccamatios by Yann Martel |
| April 9, 2010 | Tormore | 12 | Speyside | 2.80 | Smedema, Giralte, Hoover; 3.0 Sheridan, Winters; 2.5 | The Leopard by Giuseppe di Lampedusa |
| October 3, 2008 | Aberfeldy | 12 | Highland | 2.75 | Giralte, Smedema, Hoover; 3.0 Regester, Sheridan, Winters; 2.5 | The Physics of the Impossible by Michio Kaku |
| February 26, 1999 | Clynelish | Highland | 2.70 | The Night Trilogy by Elie Wiesel | ||
| March 25, 2005 | Speyburn 10 year | 10 | Highland | 2.70 | Hoover, Sheridan, Regester; 2.5 Smedema, Giralte 3.0 | No Second Chance by Harlan Coben |
| January 9, 2009 | Macallan Cask Strength | no age | Highland | 2.58 | Sheridan, Winters; 3.0 Regester, Giralte, Hoover; 2.5 Smedema; 2.0 | The Boat by Nam Le |
| June 19, 2009 | Glenfiddich | 12 | Speyside | 2.50 | Smedema; 3.5 Sheridan, Giralte, Winters, Evans; 3.0 Regester, Hoover; 2.5 | The Road by Cormac McCarthy |
| April 9, 1999 | Bowmore | Islay | 1.90 | Lincoln by David H. Donald | ||
| April 10, 1996 | Dalwhinnie | Highland | Before rating | Road To Serfdom by Friedrich Hayek | ||
| June 6, 1996 | Before rating | Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man by James Joyce | ||||
| September 6, 1996 | The Balvenie | 12 | Speyside | Not rated since this was the same Scotch from previous club meeting | Letters From the Earth by Mark Twain |